John Carter Sutton born in Spotsylvania after 1778, m 1st a double cousin, Maria Chew Sutton on 11 Jul 1811 in Caroline Co. He married 2nd Elizabeth Page Pendleton on 28 Jan 1817 also in Caroline.
I don't know the birthdate of your Norborne Elzy Sutton only that he married Dorothea Washington b 1809 d 1844 in Caroline Co. He died 9 Mar 1876 Red River Co, Texas.
There is a chancery suit that places Norborne Elzy Sutton as the brother of the above John Carter Sutton - 2 of the 5 children of William Sutton, who died before Apr 1797 and Sarah Carter b abt 1758 Spotsylvania & died after 1803 in Caroline Co. She was the daughter of John Carter (1718-1783) of Spotsylvania and his 2nd of three wives, Elizabeth Armistead (1716-1758)
Wingfield’s History of Caroline County, VA is NOT a reliable source.